FIPO – Federation of Independent Practitioner OrganisationsHarcus Parker

EXPLANATIONS

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This section of the site is intended solely for working or retired medical practitioners who have received payments from private medical insurers in the past six years. By continuing, you confirm that you are not an employee of Bupa Insurance Limited or AXA PPP Healthcare Limited, or a partner or employee of a professional adviser acting on behalf of either insurer. The content of these pages is confidential and legally privileged.

How To Join The Action Group

In order to join the Action Group, you must:

  1. 01
    Pay a subscription

    Pay a Subscription of either £250 or £500. If you pay £250, then the fee which will be deducted from any damages associated with your claim will be 32.5% + VAT; and if you pay £500 then the fee deducted from any damages associated with your claim will be 30% + VAT.

  2. 02
    Approve the terms

    Approve the terms of FIPO's engagement with Harcus Parker and Counsel on its and your behalf. This is very important, as the intention is that FIPO will execute the engagement on your behalf. It will take up the administrative burden of running the litigation for you, but the litigation will in substance remain yours, and Harcus Parker will be acting for you, so you should ensure that you are happy with the terms, which will be contracted on your behalf. In particular, you should note that the DBA with Harcus Parker will operate as though it were agreed with each member of the group. The key financial term of the DA is that if your claim succeeds, the damages associated with your claim will be reduced by a fee of 32.5% if you paid a subscription of £250 and of 30% if you paid a subscription of £500.

  3. 03
    Execute a power of attorney

    Execute a Power of Attorney in FIPO's favour authorising FIPO to bring proceedings against the PMIs on your behalf and to agree to Harcus Parker's and Counsel's retainers, and in particular to enter into a DBA with Harcus Parker on your behalf, as a result of which the damages associated with your claim will be reduced by a fee of 32.5% if you paid a subscription of £250 and of 30% if you paid a subscription of £500.

  4. 04
    Sign the agreement

    Sign a “Litigation Management Agreement” which regulates the relationship between you, FIPO, the solicitors who will be acting on your behalf and other members of the FIPO Fair Pay Action Group.

  5. 05
    Sign a declaration

    Sign a declaration which records your understanding of the main features of the arrangements.

Why This Structure?

Legal and practical reasons

  • Collective actions are most effective when strategy is centrally controlled — otherwise, defendants will exploit divisions between claimants.
  • Individual claims are not economically viable on their own. The value of your claim depends entirely on the success of the collective action.
  • Over 12,000 practitioners may be affected. Managing thousands of individual decisions is not feasible.
  • FIPO takes on the day-to-day administrative burden, freeing you to get on with your clinical work.
  • FIPO believes deeply in the justice of this cause and is committed to seeing it through.

What You Retain

  • Your right to be kept reasonably informed about the progress of the case.
  • Your right to be consulted on major decisions (where practicable, this may be via representative organizations for particular specialisms).
  • Your right to receive your proportionate share of any damages.
  • Your right to expect that FIPO will act in good faith and with reasonable care on your behalf.

How You Are Protected From Costs Risk

Any litigation carries the risk of an adverse costs order — meaning that if the Claim fails, you might be ordered to pay the defendants' legal costs. This is a real risk that we take seriously. Here is how the structure protects you:

  1. After-the-Event (ATE) Insurance: FIPO will not issue proceedings until it has arranged a suitable ATE insurance policy. This policy will cover the risk of an adverse costs order. You will not be liable for any premium unless and until the case proceeds.

  2. FIPO's Primary Liability: FIPO accepts that it has primary responsibility for any adverse costs that are not covered by insurance.

  3. Third-Party Funder: Any third-party funder of the Claim also accepts responsibility for adverse costs and — as an institution — is a more accessible target than thousands of individual practitioners.

  4. Proportionate Several Liability: Even in the unlikely worst-case scenario in which all of the above protections failed, your individual liability would be limited to your proportionate share of any adverse costs. The more practitioners who join, the smaller that share would be.

How You Benefit

  • Professional legal representation you could not afford individually;
  • Strength of collective action;
  • After-The-Event insurance protection;
  • Proportionate share of any damages recovered;
  • Pressure on Insurance companies to reform their practices.

The structure has been designed so that it is highly unlikely that you will face any personal financial liability, even if the claim is unsuccessful.

Illustration of a secured account and subscription funds

How Subscriptions Will Be Used

FIPO will hold your subscriptions on trust for the sole agreed purpose of funding the pre-action phase of the litigation and / or to pay towards the cost of ATE insurance. Specifically:

  • Subscriptions will be held in a separate, ring-fenced account (most likely a client account of Harcus Parker) entirely separate from FIPO's general funds;
  • Subscriptions will not be used for FIPO's general purposes unless and until the Claims progress beyond the pre-action phase and a balance remains after ATE insurance has been purchased. If FIPO were to become insolvent, your subscription would be protected and could not be claimed by FIPO's creditors.

Key Implications Of Joining The Action Group You Must Understand

Costs

FIPO will hold your subscriptions on trust for the sole agreed purpose of funding the pre-action phase of the litigation and / or to pay towards the cost of ATE insurance. Specifically:

  • No litigation proceeds without the risk of being ordered to pay the defendant's costs if a claim is unsuccessful.
  • But you will be protected in at least three ways:
    • FIPO will not issue proceedings unless it has arranged a suitable policy of After The Event insurance to protect you from the impact of an adverse costs judgment;
    • FIPO acknowledges that it itself will have the primary responsibility to a pay adverse costs, should the insurance fail or be insufficient; and
    • Any third-party funder of the claim will similarly be responsible for adverse costs, and will be an easier target than thousands of individuals.
  • As a consequence of this structure, it is highly unlikely that you will face any personal liability.

How Damages Will Be Distributed

If the case succeeds at trial, a specific amount will be allocated to each practitioner's claim (or a formula will be set out which leads to a specific amount). Settlement, however, provides for more flexibility, and the text below describes what is likely to happen. The following example uses illustrative figures only and does not represent any estimate of the value of the Claims.

  1. Receipt Of Funds

    Funds are received from defendants into Harcus Parker's client account. A specialist class action administrator such as GC Partners or Shield Pay is likely to be used to distribute the funds.

  2. Deduction Of Costs

    • Legal fees, expert fees, court fees and expenses not recovered from the Defendants;
    • The cost of deferred insurance premiums; and
    • Administration costs.

    Illustrative example: if £50 million is received and total costs are £8 million, the net fund available for distribution is £42 million.

  3. Individual Allocation

    If the court has awarded specific amounts to specific practitioners, or if specific amounts have been negotiated, those amounts are paid. If a global sum has been agreed for distribution among all members (which is a common feature of group action settlements), Step 4 applies.

  4. Proportionate Share Calculation

    Expert economists will calculate each member's Proportionate Share based on:

    • Their individual PMI income during the relevant period;
    • Their practice characteristics;
    • Competitive market fee analysis (which may vary from specialism to specialism); and
    • Their documented losses.
  5. DBA Fee Deduction And Payment

    The DBA fee (32.5% or 30% + VAT, depending on your subscription level) is deducted from your Proportionate Share, and the net amount is paid to you.

Worked Example (illustrative figures only)

Total damages after costs: £42 million

Total members: 500

Your individual documented losses: £300,000

Total documented losses (all members): £150 million

Your Proportionate Share: (£300,000 / £150 million) × £42 million = £84,000

Less DBA fee (32.5% + VAT, standard member): approx. £32,760

Tax Implications

IMPORTANT: Neither FIPO nor Harcus Parker will advise you on tax matters. The following is general information only, not tax advice. You should consult your own tax adviser.

Damages received in compensation for lost income are generally treated as taxable income by HMRC. You should be aware of the following:

  • Damages for lost income are typically taxable as income in the year of receipt, although it may be possible to spread the charge across the years to which the losses relate.
  • You may be able to deduct legal costs from the damages received for tax purposes.
  • You should inform your accountant about your participation in the Claim when filing your tax returns.

Descriptions Of The Documents And How To Execute Or Approve Them

  1. The Retainer and Damages-Based Agreement with Harcus Parker

    FIPO will enter into this agreement on your behalf, exercising the authority you give it under the Power of Attorney. The DBA means that if your claim succeeds, Harcus Parker’s fees will be deducted from your damages (at the rate of 32.5% or 30% + VAT depending on your subscription level). If your claim does not succeed, you will owe Harcus Parker nothing.

  2. The Power of Attorney

    This is the key document. By signing it, you authorise FIPO to bring your claim on your behalf, to instruct lawyers on your behalf, and to make all decisions in relation to your claim — including whether and when to settle. You should read it carefully.

    The Power of Attorney becomes irrevocable after a 14-day cooling-off period. If you die or become incapacitated while the Claim is ongoing, the Power of Attorney will be automatically revoked and your personal representatives will need to execute a new one to continue your claim.

  3. The Litigation Management Agreement (LMA)

    The LMA is the agreement between you, FIPO and Harcus Parker that governs how the Claim is run. It covers: decision-making, your obligations to cooperate (including providing disclosure and potentially giving evidence), how costs are shared, and how damages are distributed.

  4. The Overarching Declaration

    The LMA is the agreement between you, FIPO and Harcus Parker that governs how the Claim is run. It covers: decision-making, your obligations to cooperate (including providing disclosure and potentially giving evidence), how costs are shared, and how damages are distributed.

Fipo’s Engagement With Harcus Parker and Counsel, Including the DBA It Will Execute on Your Behalf With Your Approval

This sets out the terms on which Harcus Parker will act for FIPO in the prosecution of your claim. It will enter the agreement with Harcus Parker for you and as you. You should read the entire document, but note:

How To Upload Your Evidence

After completing the sign-up process, you will be asked to upload documents evidencing your relationship with Bupa and/or AXA PPP. This is important: your share of any damages will be calculated by reference to the fees you received from the insurers, so the more complete your evidence, the better.

What to Upload

  • Fee schedules received from Bupa or AXA PPP (any years for which you have them);
  • Correspondence with the insurers about fees or recognition;
  • Payment records or remittance advices from the insurers;
  • Any specialist recognition letters or agreements; and
  • Any other documents relating to your financial relationship with the insurers.

What Format?

Documents can be uploaded as PDFs, Word documents, images (JPG or PNG), or Excel spreadsheets. Please label them clearly (e.g. 'Bupa fee schedule 2022', 'AXA correspondence March 2024').

What If I Don't Have Much Documentation?

Don't worry — join the Claim anyway. Harcus Parker will work with you to reconstruct your fee history, including by requesting information directly from the insurers on your behalf. The more members who join, the stronger the overall evidential picture.

Document Hold

DOCUMENT HOLD NOTICE: By joining the Action Group, you are required from the date of your membership to preserve all documents and data in your possession, custody or control that may be relevant to the Claims. This includes emails, letters, fee schedules, payment records and any other communications with or about Bupa or AXA PPP. Do not delete, destroy or overwrite any such documents. This obligation applies even if the documents would otherwise be subject to routine deletion under your data retention policy.

Summary Risk Warning

No Guarantee of Success
This is litigation, not an investment. There is no guarantee we will win or recover any damages. You could lose your entire contribution if the case fails.
Time Commitment
Complex litigation typically takes 2-5 years. Be prepared for a long process with no quick resolution.
Costs Protection
We will have ATE insurance to protect against having to pay defendants' costs if we lose. However, your contribution is at risk and insurance cannot remove the theoretical risk of the insurance failing.
Irrevocability
Once you sign the legal documents, you cannot easily withdraw.
Tax Implications
Any damages you receive may be taxable. Seek independent tax advice.